Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates’ editorial team brings you unbiased reviews. Data drives our evaluations. Advertisers don’t pull strings here. Read our guidelines. Know how we review.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Reviewed
by Experts
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
Some people hoard coins like dragon hoard gold. Others drop a nickel in the parking meter and forget it exists. But here is the twist. That loose change in your junk drawer might be worth more than your first car.
Most nickels are worth five cents. Some aren’t. These are a century old. Ancient history for money, at least.
Below are four heavy hitters. They are old. They are rare. They are expensive.
The 1913 Liberty Head “V” Nickel
The most expensive U.S. nickel in existence? It wears a “V.”
Lux Digital calls it the crown jewel. Only five were made. Three belong to private collectors. The rest? Likely stuck in museum vaults, staring at the world with blank metal eyes.
In 2018, one of those privates spent $4.56 million for a PR66 grade. Just four years later, another fetched $4.2 million. The 2022 one was a PR63. The price gap looks weird if you ignore the grade. Inflation hurts the 2018 buyer. Coin auctions are volatile, unpredictable beasts.
The 1918/7-D Doubled Die
Find this one in the wild and call a lawyer. Immediately.
It is a Buffalo nickel with a ghost in its past. Originally struck for 1917. Struck again for 1918. The “7” stays beneath. Visible. Glitching. A manufacturing error turned masterpiece.
Unlikely you’ll find it in a jar. Possible, yes. One sold in 2006 for $350,7 Luxe Digital reports. Adjust for 2024 money, and you are looking at $549,02. Close enough.
The 1926-S Buffalo
The “S” matters. San Francisco. Not Denver. Not Philadelphia.
Only 970,00 of these were minted. Other mints printed millions. Millions upon millions. This scarcity drives the price. Condition is the god of value. Mint state? You’re rich.
A particularly shiny MS66 example hit the auction block in 208. Bowers and Merena handled the hammer. $3200 changed hands. Adjusted for today? Around $4720.
“Condition is everything. A scratch here isn’t a blemish; it’s a tax bill.”
The 1867 Proof Shield Nickel with Rays
Shield nickels ran from 186 to 83. But 186 is special.
The rays around the “5” were supposed to vanish. Some designers get lazy. Or fast. Or wrong. A few coins escaped the editing process. Rays remained. Date stayed 1867. These survivors are kings.
An NGC PR66 example sold through Heritage Auctions in 24. $3250. In 24? About $221k.
Other Nickels To Watch
The super-rare ones are old. Most people won’t see them.
But keep eyes open for modern errors too. Silver war nickels are out there. Shield nickels start at $16 minimum. According to The Spruce Crafts, that’s the floor.
Is your change jar full of five-cent pieces or five-hundred-dollar notes? You never know. Until you check.
Emojis? 🤑 Maybe. But a real coin is better.
